XXQ Refinishing vs Remodeling Cultured Marble Bathtubs: Which is Better? - Refinishing 101

A black text on a black background.

Refinishing vs Remodeling Cultured Marble Bathtubs: Which is Better?

Posted by

Key Takeaways

  • Cultured marble bathtubs can be revitalized with a refinishing process, which is cost-effective and less labor-intensive than a full remodel.

  • The refinishing process involves cleaning, sanding, priming, applying a new finish, and sealing the tub.

  • A full remodel is recommended if the bathtub is extensively damaged or if you want a complete design overhaul.

  • Maintaining a refinished or newly installed cultured marble tub is essential to extend its lifespan and preserve its appearance.

  • Homeowners should weigh the condition of their tub, budget, and end goals when deciding between refinishing and remodeling.

What’s at Stake? Cultured Marble Bathtubs

Imagine stepping into a bathroom where the centerpiece, a gleaming cultured marble bathtub, invites you for a relaxing soak. Now, if your tub has lost its luster or bears the scars of daily use, don’t fret. You’ve got options. Two of the most popular choices are refinishing or remodeling. Both paths can breathe new life into your bathroom, but the right choice depends on various factors, including condition, cost, and your ultimate vision for the space.

Defining Cultured Marble

Before diving into the nitty-gritty of renovation, let’s clarify what we mean by ‘cultured marble.’ This material is a blend of natural stone particles and resins, topped with a clear gel coat. It provides the opulent look of marble without the hefty price tag. Because it’s man-made, cultured marble comes in a variety of shapes and sizes, making it a versatile choice for homeowners.

Why Choose Cultured Marble

Cultured marble is not just about aesthetics; it’s also known for its durability and ease of maintenance. Unlike natural stone, it doesn’t require sealing and is less prone to staining. That said, over time, the gel coat may wear down, leading to dullness or cracks. When that happens, you’re faced with a decision: to refinish or to remodel.

The Refinishing Route

If your tub is generally in good shape but has minor cosmetic issues, refinishing is a practical choice. You can easily refinish your tub for $480. It’s a project that can be completed within a few days and doesn’t require a full bathroom shutdown. Let’s walk through the steps.

DIY Steps to Refinish Your Tub

Step 1: Cleaning the Surface

The first step is to give your bathtub a thorough cleaning. Any soap scum, hard water deposits, or body oils must be removed to ensure the new finish adheres properly. Use a non-abrasive cleaner and a sponge or soft cloth to get the job done.

Step 2: Sanding for Smoothness

Next, you’ll want to sand the surface. This creates a rough texture that helps the new finish stick. A medium-grit sandpaper should do the trick. Be sure to sand evenly to avoid gouging the surface.

Step 3: Priming for Perfection

After sanding, apply a primer. This acts as a base coat and is critical for a smooth, even finish. Let the primer dry according to the manufacturer’s instructions before moving on.

Step 4: Applying New Finish

Now, it’s time for the new finish. This could be a paint specifically designed for bathtubs or a new gel coat similar to the original. Apply it evenly and allow it to dry completely.

Step 5: Sealing the Deal

The final step is sealing. This locks in the new finish and adds an extra layer of protection. Once sealed, your bathtub should look as good as new.

Pros of Refinishing

Refinishing has several advantages. It’s cost-effective, usually running a fraction of the price of a full remodel. It’s also faster and less disruptive to your daily life. Plus, it’s an environmentally friendly option since you’re not sending a large fixture to the landfill.

Supplies You’ll Need

  • Non-abrasive cleaner

  • Sponge or soft cloth

  • Medium-grit sandpaper

  • Primer designed for bathtubs

  • Finish or paint for bathtubs

  • Sealant

Full Remodel Breakdown

When refinishing won’t cut it, a full remodel may be in order. This is a bigger commitment, both in terms of time and money, but it’s the way to go if you’re looking for a total transformation. A full remodel allows you to completely customize your bathroom’s look, feel, and functionality.

Remodeling involves more than just the bathtub; it’s an opportunity to rethink your entire bathroom’s design. You can change the layout, update the fixtures, and even choose new materials for a fresh, modern look. But remember, with greater change comes greater responsibility. You’ll need to carefully plan and budget for a successful remodel.

As with any significant home improvement project, it’s critical to partner with experienced professionals who can guide you through the process and ensure a high-quality finish. From plumbers to tile setters, having the right team can make all the difference.

Removing the Old Tub

Before you can bring in the new, you’ve got to take out the old. Removing a cultured marble tub is a job for professionals. They’ll ensure the tub is removed without damaging surrounding areas. Once the tub is out, you’ll have a blank canvas for your new design.

Exploring Design Options

With the old tub out, you’re free to explore all sorts of design options. Maybe you’ll go for a classic clawfoot tub or a modern alcove tub with crisp, clean lines. You can choose colors and materials that complement your personal style and the overall aesthetic of your home.

Setting Up for the New Look

Once you’ve selected your new tub and design elements, it’s time to set everything up. This could involve adjusting plumbing, reinforcing the floor, or even moving walls to accommodate your vision. Each change should be carefully considered and executed to ensure a seamless and functional result.

The Costs Involved

Now, let’s talk numbers. A full bathroom remodel can range significantly in cost, depending on the extent of the changes and the materials you choose. Here’s a rough breakdown:

  • A new cultured marble tub can cost between $1,500 and $2,500.

  • Installation and labor costs can add another $1,000 to $3,000 to the bill.

  • Additional elements like tiles, fixtures, and plumbing can push the total cost even higher.

Decision Time: Refinish or Remodel?

So, you’ve got the facts. Now it’s decision time. To make the best choice for your bathroom, you’ll need to assess your tub’s condition, consider your budget, and think about what you want to achieve with the space.

Refinishing vs Remodeling: Advantages and Disadvantages

RefinishingRemodeling
Cost$480$1,500 to $2,500+
Timeline2 to 3 daysSeveral weeks
ProsCost-effective, less disruptive, environmentally friendlyFull customization, improves functionality, long-term solution
ConsLimited to repairing only the aesthetics or cosmetic issuesLonger process, more disruptive, high initial investment
Longevity10 to 15 years with proper careDecades with proper care

Assessing Tub Condition

If your tub has minor blemishes or dullness, refinishing is a viable and budget-friendly option. But if you’re dealing with deep cracks, leaks, or structural issues, it might be time to remodel. Consider how much life is left in your current tub and whether a refresh will be enough.

Comparing Timeframes and Budgets

Refinishing can be done in a few days, while a remodel could leave you without a bathroom for weeks. Budget-wise, refinishing is the clear winner if funds are tight. But if you’re prepared to invest more for a long-term solution, remodeling could be the way to go.

Remember, refinishing can often extend the life of your cultured marble tub by 10 to 15 years, while a new tub can last for decades with proper care.

End Goals: Aesthetics vs. Functionality

What’s driving your decision? If it’s purely about looks, refinishing can work wonders. But if you’re looking to improve functionality, change the layout, or upgrade to a more luxurious experience, remodeling is your answer.

Maintenance Tips Post-Renovation

Whether you choose to refinish or remodel, taking care of your cultured marble tub is key to maintaining its beauty and extending its life. Here are some tips to keep it looking its best:

Extending Your Tub’s Lifespan

After all the effort you’ve put into refinishing or remodeling, you’ll want to ensure your cultured marble tub stays in tip-top shape for as long as possible. Regular maintenance is key. A gentle cleaning routine, avoiding abrasive materials, and keeping an eye out for minor repairs will go a long way in preserving the life and look of your tub.

Daily and Weekly Care Recommendations

For daily maintenance, a quick wipe-down after use can prevent water spots and build-up. Weekly, you should spend a little more time with a non-abrasive cleaner, paying attention to any crevices or jets. Avoid using scouring pads or harsh chemicals that can scratch or damage the surface. It’s all about gentle care to keep that new or newly refinished tub shining.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How Long Does Refinishing Take Compared to Remodeling?

Refinishing a cultured marble tub is relatively quick – it can typically be done in two to three days. Remodeling, on the other hand, can take several weeks, depending on the extent of the work and the complexity of the project. The key is to set realistic timeframes and plan accordingly.

Can I Refinish a Cultured Marble Tub Myself?

Yes, it’s possible to refinish a cultured marble tub yourself if you’re handy and have the right tools and materials. However, achieving a professional finish can be challenging. If you’re not confident in your DIY skills, it’s worth hiring a professional to ensure a smooth, durable finish.

Is Remodeling a Cultured Marble Tub Worth the Investment?

Remodeling can be a significant investment, but it’s worth considering if your current tub is beyond repair or if you’re looking to completely change your bathroom’s layout or style. It can increase your home’s value and enhance your daily experience, making it a worthwhile investment for many homeowners.

Current trends in bathtub designs lean towards minimalist lines, natural materials, and spa-like features such as built-in therapy jets or soaking depths. Freestanding tubs are particularly popular, as they can serve as a statement piece in your bathroom’s design.

How Often Should I Reseal My Refinished Cultured Marble Tub?

It’s generally recommended to reseal a refinished cultured marble tub every one to two years, depending on usage and the type of sealant used. Regular resealing helps protect the finish from wear and tear, keeping it waterproof and looking new.

There you have it – whether you opt for refinishing or a full remodel, your cultured marble tub can be the crown jewel of your bathroom. With the right care, either option can provide you with a beautiful, functional space that you’ll enjoy for years to come. The most important thing is to choose what works best for your lifestyle, budget, and design preferences.

Author

  • Amna

    Editor & Researcher Amna is a writer and editor with a background in producing engaging content for various publications like Homelight, and many small home improvement businesses around the United States, Canada, and the U.K. A huge fan of shows like Property Brothers and This Old House, she loves learning how to make her home more beautiful, wherever in the world that home happens to be this year.

    View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *